Gutter guards are the most-asked-about add-on on any estimate we do, and the honest answer is: it depends on your trees. A house in Bellmore under mature oaks and maples fills an open gutter twice a fall. A house in a newer development with young trees might go years without a clog. Guards make sense in the first case and are mostly wasted money in the second.
What guards do well is keep out leaves, twigs, and the big debris that causes overflow. What they don't do is make gutters maintenance-free. Pine needles, maple seeds, and roof grit still land on top, and every guard system needs a rinse or brush-off once a year to keep water flowing. Anyone who tells you "never clean your gutters again" is selling something.
The style matters more than the brand. Micro-mesh guards handle the widest range of debris and shed water reliably in heavy rain. Reverse-curve guards look sleek but tend to overshoot water in downpours and shed leaves onto the ground below. Cheap foam and brush inserts clog from the inside and are not worth installing.
Our recommendation: if you're already getting new seamless gutters and you have real tree coverage, add micro-mesh guards to the runs under the trees and leave the rest open. You get most of the benefit for a fraction of the cost, and you can always add more later.